India
BJP alleges Himachal Congress government faces repeated court setbacks over unconstitutional laws
Photo: the times of india

BJP alleges Himachal Congress government faces repeated court setbacks over unconstitutional laws

The Himachal Pradesh High Court struck down the state government's role in appointing university vice‑chancellors, and BJP leader Jairam Thakur warned that the Sukhu‑led Congress is repeatedly losing battles in courts over statutes he calls unconstitutional.

The Himachal Pradesh High Court on Tuesday ruled that the state government's involvement in the appointment of vice‑chancellors to state universities violates constitutional provisions. The judgment nullified a set of notifications that had allowed the chief minister’s office to nominate candidates for the top academic posts, a move the court said infringed on the autonomy guaranteed to higher education institutions under the Indian Constitution. The decision came after a petition filed by the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) challenged the legality of the appointments, arguing that the executive branch had overstepped its authority.

BJP state president Jairam Thakur seized on the verdict, stating that it was another example of the Congress‑led government in Himachal Pradesh repeatedly facing setbacks in courts over laws he described as unconstitutional. Thakur cited earlier judgments that had struck down provisions related to land acquisition and anti‑encroachment measures, suggesting a pattern of legal defeats for the Sukhu administration. He urged the public to view the High Court’s ruling as evidence of the Congress’s disregard for constitutional limits.

ALSO READ | India and ASEAN Nations Chart Scalable Agricultural Cooperation at Summit

Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu’s government, which came to power in December 2022, defended the appointments as necessary to ensure merit‑based leadership in the state’s universities. The administration has indicated it will appeal the decision, asserting that the notifications were issued after extensive consultations with academic bodies and were intended to streamline the selection process.

The legal tussle adds to a growing list of disputes between the state’s ruling party and the opposition, with both sides preparing for the next electoral cycle. The High Court’s order not only affects the immediate governance of higher‑education institutions but also sets a precedent that could influence how state governments across India draft and implement similar statutes.

Video: Congress will get another setback in Himachal Pradesh, dozens of leaders will leave the party
Watch on YouTube ↗
Why This Matters

The judgment underscores the delicate balance between state authority and institutional autonomy in India’s federal structure. By declaring the government's role in vice‑chancellor appointments unconstitutional, the court reaffirms the principle that educational institutions must operate free from undue political interference, a safeguard for academic freedom and meritocracy. For the Congress government in Himachal Pradesh, the ruling is a political setback that could erode its credibility ahead of upcoming state elections, especially as the opposition frames it as a pattern of overreach.

Legally, the decision may serve as a reference point for other states that have attempted to centralise control over university leadership. It could prompt a review of similar statutes nationwide, compelling governments to redesign appointment processes to align with constitutional mandates. Politically, the episode intensifies the rivalry between the BJP and Congress in the hill state, with each side likely to leverage the court’s verdict to rally supporters and shape public perception in the run‑up to the next electoral contest.

Reporting based on verified dispatches from Times of India. View primary release ↗
Stay Connected
Follow SamacharDaily on Instagram

Visual explainers, infographics, and daily news briefings on your feed.

More in India